HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda Packet - EVWD Board of Directors - 02/08/2017REGULAR BOARD MEETING
Closed Session Begins at 4:30 PM
February 8, 2017 - 5:30 PM
31111 Greenspot Road, Highland, CA 92346
AGENDA
"In order to comply with legal requirements for posting of agenda, only those items filed
with the District Clerk by 12:00 p.m. on Wednesday prior to the following Wednesday
meeting not requiring departmental investigation, will be considered by the Board of
Directors".
CALL TO ORDER
ROLL CALL OF BOARD MEMBERS
PUBLIC COMMENTS
Any person wishing to speak to the Board of Directors is asked to complete a Speaker
Card and submit it to the District Clerk prior to the start of the meeting. Each speaker is
limited to three (3) minutes, unless waived by the Chairman of the Board. Under the State
of California Brown Act, the Board of Directors is prohibited from discussing or taking
action on any item not listed on the posted agenda. The matter will automatically be
referred to staff for an appropriate response or action and may appear on the agenda at a
future meeting.
AGENDA - This agenda contains a brief general description of each item to be
considered. Except as otherwise provided by law, no action shall be taken on any item not
appearing on the following agenda unless the Board of Directors makes a determination
that an emergency exists or that a need to take immediate action on the item came to the
attention of the District subsequent to the posting of the agenda.
1.Approval of Agenda
RECESS INTO CLOSED SESSION
CLOSED SESSION
2.CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL - EXISTING LITIGATION
[Government Code Section 54956.9(d) (1)]
Name of Case: Socal Environmental Justice Alliance v. San Bernardino Valley
Municipal Water District, et al.,
San Diego Superior Court Case No. 37-2016-00032816-CU-TT-CTL
3.CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL - EXISTING LITIGATION
[Government Code Section 54956.9(d) (1)]
Name of Case: City of San Bernardino v. East Valley Water District, et al.,
San Diego Superior Court Case No. 37-2016-00038119-CU-WM-CTL
4.CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL - EXISTING LITIGATION
[Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(1)]
Name of Case: Carl F. Kovach v. East Valley Water District, CASE No. CIVDS
1603176
5:30 PM RECONVENE MEETING
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
ROLL CALL OF BOARD MEMBERS
ANNOUNCEMENT OF CLOSED SESSION ACTIONS ITEMS
PUBLIC COMMENTS
5.APPROVAL OF CONSENT CALENDAR
All matters listed under the Consent Calendar are considered by the Board of
Directors to be routine and will be enacted in one motion. There will be no
discussion of these items prior to the time the board considers the motion unless
members of the board, the administrative staff, or the public request specific items to
be discussed and/or removed from the Consent Calendar.
a.Directors' fees and expenses for January 2017
INFORMATIONAL ITEMS
6.PayNearMe Project Update
7.Automated Metering Infrastructure Update
REPORTS
8.Board of Directors' Reports
9.General Manager/CEO Report
10.Legal Counsel Report
11.Board of Directors' Comments
ADJOURN
P LEASE NOT E:
Materials related to an item on this agenda s ub mitted to the Board after dis trib utio n of the agenda pac ket
are available for p ublic inspec tio n in the Dis tric t's offic e loc ated at 31111 G reens pot Rd., Highland , during
no rmal bus iness ho urs. Als o, s uc h d o c uments are availab le o n the District's web s ite at www.eas tvalley.o rg
sub ject to s taff's ab ility to post the d o cuments b efo re the meeting.
P ursuant to Go vernment Co d e S ectio n 54954.2(a), any reques t fo r a dis ability-related modific ation or
ac commod ation, inc luding auxiliary aids or s ervic es , that is s ought in order to participate in the abo ve-
agendized p ublic meeting sho uld b e direc ted to the Dis tric t Clerk at (909) 885-4900 at leas t 72 hours prior
to said meeting.
Recommended by:
Jo hn Mura
General Manager/CEO
Res p ec tfully s ub mitted :
Justine Hendric ks en
Dis tric t Clerk
BOARD AGENDA STAFF REPORT
Agenda Item #5.a.
Meeting Date: February 8, 2017
Co nsent Item
To: Governing Bo ard Memb ers
From: General Manager/CEO
Subject: Direc tors ' fees and exp ens es for January 2017
RECOMMENDATION:
Ap p ro ve the Governing Board Memb ers ’ fees and expens es fo r January 2017.
BACKGROUND / ANALYSIS:
T he Board has instruc ted staff to lis t all d irec tor fees and exp ens es as a s ep arate agenda item to s how full fisc al
transparenc y. O nly after Board review and ap p ro val will the c o mpens ation and exp ens es be p aid.
AGENCY IDEALS AND ENDEAVORS:
Ideals and Endeavor II - Maintain An Enviro nment Committed To Elevated P ublic Servic e
(E) – Practice transparent & acc o untab le fis cal management
REVIEW BY OTHERS:
T his agend a items has been reviewed b y the Ad minis tratio n department.
FISCAL IMPACT :
T he fis c al imp ac t as s o c iated with this agenda item is $6,562.97 whic h is inc luded in the c urrent fisc al b udget.
ATTACHMENTS:
Description Type
Directors Fees and Expenses January 2017 Backup Material
BOARD AGENDA STAFF REPORT
Agend a Item #6.
Meeting Date: February 8, 2017
Dis cus s io n Item
To: Governing Bo ard Memb ers
From: General Manager/CEO
Subject: P ayNearMe P ro jec t Update
RECOMMENDATION:
T his item is pres ented fo r info rmatio n only.
BACKGROUND / ANALYSIS:
Staff is p leas ed to p rovid e a c urrent up d ate on the P ayNearMe program, las t rep o rted on to the Bo ard at the
Sep tember 14, 2016 regular bo ard meeting.
Sinc e Sep tember, s taff has worked with PayNearMe’s Imp lementatio n Team to plac e barc o des and ins truc tions
o n cus tomer b ills , and to ens ure that the P ayNearMe tec hno lo gy was integrated with the Distric t’s utility billing
s ys tem s o that c usto mer p ayments are properly rec o rd ed and ap plied to their EVWD acc o unts .
On Oc tober 6, 2016 the offic ial go-live date was announc ed and EVWD c us tomers rec eived b arc o d es on their
b ills and were ab le to utilize this new payment o p tion at 7-11 and Family Do llar s tores .
T he s uc ces s ful roll out of the PayNearMe program was fo llo wed o n No vemb er 30, 2016 by the
d ec o mmissioning of the two p ayment kio s ks lo cated at Rio Rancho Market and S up er Penny Mart. Sinc e the
go -live date, the Dis trict has received 512 p ayments to taling $51,768.60 thro ugh PayNearMe. The direct c os t to
the District was $1,018.88 (512 p ayments x $1.99 p er payment), whic h is approximately $4,500.00 les s than the
c o s ts that wo uld have been inc urred if the s ame payments had been p ro c es s ed b y the Kiosks .
Staff will c o ntinue to monitor and evaluate the PayNearMe p ro gram to ensure EVWD c usto mers continue to
rec eive wo rld c lass p ub lic s ervice.
AGENCY IDEALS AND ENDEAVORS:
Ideals and Endeavor II - Maintain An Enviro nment Committed To Elevated P ublic Servic e
(A) - Strive to pro vide wo rld class c usto mer relations
Ideals and Endeavor IV - Fully Unders tand Challenges To Cultivate Effective So lutio ns
(E) - Conduct po s t implementation evaluations and make imp ro vements as nec es s ary
Recommended by:
Jo hn Mura
General Manager/CEO
Res p ec tfully s ub mitted :
Nathaniel P ared es
Bus ines s S ervic es Manager
FISCAL IMPACT :
T here is no fis c al imp ac t as s o c iated with this agenda item.
ATTACHMENTS:
Description Type
PayNearMe P re sentation Presentation
1
•Go-Live Date October 6, 2016
•Direct Cost Associated with the
PayNearMe Solution:
−$1,018.88
•Approximately $4,500
Year-To -Date Savings
•Continue Customer Outreach and
Monitor Effectiveness of the Program
PAYNEARME
E A S T V A L L E Y W A T E R D I S T R I C T 2
PAYNEARME
No. Customers0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Oct 2016 Nov 2016 Dec 2016 Jan 2017
Customers by Month
3E A S T V A L L E Y W A T E R D I S T R I C T
512 Successful
Payments
Received to Date
Year-to-Date
Payments Received
Total $52,000
PAYNEARME
Cost Per Transaction
$-
$1.00
$2.00
$3.00
$4.00
$5.00
$6.00
$7.00
Kiosks PayNearMe
Cost Per Transaction
Kiosk
Transaction
Cost
$6.52
PayNearMe
Transaction
Cost
$1.99
Per
Transaction
Cost Savings
$4.53
Cost Savings
To Date $4,500.00
FY 2016-17
Projected
Savings
$24,000.00
E A S T V A L L E Y W A T E R D I S T R I C T 4
E A S T V A L L E Y W A T E R D I S T R I C T
CUSTOMER OUTREACH
5
ADDITIONAL PAYMENT METHODS
•Online
•By Mail
•In Person at District Office
•Payment Drop Box
•By Phone
•Automatic Payment Plan
•District Headquarters
Payment Kiosk
Cash
Check
Money
Orders
Credit Cards
6E A S T V A L L E Y W A T E R D I S T R I C T
7
BOARD AGENDA STAFF REPORT
Agend a Item #7.
Meeting Date: February 8, 2017
Dis cus s io n Item
To: Governing Bo ard Memb ers
From: General Manager/CEO
Subject: Automated Metering Infrastruc ture Update
RECOMMENDATION:
T his agend a item is pres ented fo r informatio n only.
BACKGROUND / ANALYSIS:
Timely rep lac ement o f water meters is an imp o rtant long-term maintenanc e pro gram. The Distric t s uc ces s fully
rec eived over $2 millio n in grant fund s to rep lac e existing meters with “s mart meters” for qualifying
d isadvantaged cus tomers .
Prio r to beginning meter rep lacement, nec es s ary tec hnology infrastruc ture was put in p lac e. In November 2016
d ata c o llec tors were installed at eight Dis trict fac ilities res ulting in ap p roximately 90% rad io coverage over the
s ervice area. T his will allow fo r water use info rmatio n to b e relayed fro m the cus tomer meter to the District
head q uarters without req uiring a s taff memb er to manually gather the d ata. This eq uipment is the fo undatio n fo r
the s uc ces s of the smart meters , and will b e us ed by ad d itional phases witho ut the need for d ata collecto r
exp ans ion.
Ad vanc ed Metering Infras truc ture (AMI) meter ins tallation o ffic ially began in January 2017. With a to tal o f the
7,100 meters s c hed uled fo r rep lacement, 3,400 are radio read meters whic h will o nly require a retro fit in o rd er to
b e c onverted to AMI. The p ro jec t will be c omp leted in groups b as ed up o n meter read ro utes. T here are 30 meter
read ro utes includ ed in the p ro jec t and as o f the d ate o f this rep o rt, three ro utes have b een c o mp leted to taling
745 meters . T he project is s ched uled fo r completion in s pring 2017, however heavy rains may res ult in weather
d elays c aus ing an extens io n o f this time frame.
In early January, the District s ent letters to the 7,100 cus to mers whose meters will be rep lac ed in this p ro jec t. A
s mall numb er o f res idents c o ntac ted s taff with q ues tions regard ing the ins tallation o f the AMI meter. Due to the
c urrent us e of AMI technology by SoCalGas and So uthern Califo rnia Ed is o n, the District anticipated a s mo o th
implementation. A s mall number o f cus tomers have vo iced c o ncern ab o ut the radio-wave tec hnology. In order to
fully addres s this is s ue and assis t c usto mers with feeling c o nfident in the new pro gram, staff is evaluating
p otential solutions. While this is taking place thos e p ro perties will not rec eive new meters . One optio n b eing
c o nsidered is required of fo r-p ro fit p rivate utilities, but not p ublic utilities, is an o pportunity to “o p t-out”. S taff is
assessing the feasibility of this o p tion amo ng o ther ad d itional p ro gram c ons id eratio ns .
Staff is c o mmitted to cond ucting community engagement at a future date to dis c us s the remaining conc erns and
p resent additio nal information as to any health and safety issues s urround ing the us e o f AMI meters. S taff will
Recommended by:
Jo hn Mura
General Manager/CEO
Res p ec tfully s ub mitted :
Steven Nix
Directo r o f Engineering & Op eratio ns
p resent additio nal information as to any health and safety issues s urround ing the us e o f AMI meters. S taff will
also b e prep ared to d is c uss the es tablis hment of an “Op t Out” p rogram if determined to b e needed.
AGENCY IDEALS AND ENDEAVORS:
Ideals and Endeavor I - Enc o urage Innovative Investments To Pro mo te Sustainab le Benefits
(D) - Ded icate effo rt toward s ys tem maintenance and modernization
FISCAL IMPACT :
T here is no fis c al imp ac t as s o c iated with this agenda item.
ATTACHMENTS:
Description Type
AMI Update Presentation
1
•Multi-Year Project to Replace All Manually
Read Meters with Automated Metering Infrastructure
2EAST VALLEY WATER DISTRICT
PROJECT OVERVIEW
Funded by $2,011,465 Water-Energy Grant from State Dept. of Water Resources
8 Data Collectors –90% Coverage of District Service Area
7,100 Meters within the District Service Area
Customers Access Water Usage on Utility Billing Website
PHASE 1
EAST VALLEY WATER DISTRICT
PHASE I AMI METER REPLACEMENTS
3
Meters were
Selected Based
on Grant
Funding Criteria
$2 Million Grant
744 Meters
Replaced in
January 2017
44
•Data Collectors
−Installed at Various District Plants
−Additional Collectors to be Installed
with New Development
•8 Collector Sites
•98.9% Coverage
EAST VALLEY WATER DISTRICT
INSTALLATION
5EAST VALLEY WATER DISTRICT
PHASE I PROJECT TIMELINE
Data Collectors
Installed
Nov 2016
SUS Portal
Dec 2016
Network
Activated
Dec 2016
Public Outreach
Jan –Aug 2017
Meter
Installation
Jan –Apr 2017
Phase I
Completed
Aug 2017
66
•Meters
−20 Year Life
−New Lids with Flush Mounted Antennas
−Relays Water Use Data Hourly
EAST VALLEY WATER DISTRICT
INSTALLATION
•14,000 Installed Over
Next 4 Years in Phases
•Addressing Questions Regarding Health Concerns
−Radio Frequency Emissions (RF)
•Customers May Request a hold of Meter
Installation
−Staff will be Tracking
•Conduct Public Outreach to Discuss Concerns
and Resolutions
−Evaluating Feasibility of “Opt Out” Provision
•Reaching out to Utilities Currently Using AMI
7EAST VALLEY WATER DISTRICT
HEALTH AND SAFETY CONCERNS
Currently Use AMI Technology
within our Service Area
8EAST VALLEY WATER DISTRICT
COMMUNICATION